The Little Movie that Just Might: Atlas Shrugged, Part One

Urban Planning and Transportation of Utah writes a weekly blog centered around Amtrak. “This week at Amtrak, Vol. 8 No 9″ begins,

For something completely different, This Week goes to the movies, plus some observations by URPA Vice President of Corporate Communications Russ Jackson.

To be clear, Atlas Shrugged may not win any Academy awards. But that is not the point. The tale behind bringing Ayn Rand’s 1957 novel to the big screen is almost as long as the book itself. Loathed or loved, public sentiment is anything but neutral for Atlas Shrugged

From a literary standpoint, the movie succeeds. All the main points are visited: Hard work, and the virtue of the reward for such hard work, lead to progress; rewarding those who do not contribute will ultimately lead to ruin; the inequity of expecting industry to respond to critics whose sole job it is to criticize. That is not, however, the reason one goes to the movie theater.

In spite of it all, the film does work. It is rather dense, and as such will sail clear over the heads of the average moviegoer. It is a thinking movie for a thinking audience. Is the free market the answer to all our problems? Of course not; but neither is the free market so infinitely large as to subsidize everything else. Some may see this as a political statement, others as social commentary. In the words of Alfred Hitchcock, “It’s only a movie.”

I guess Amtrak executives cannot pass up the opportunity to write about trains, especially when the movie centers around the protagonist’s fight to save her railroad. Thanks for the plug, Mr. Jackson.

This entry was posted in Ayn Rand's philosophy, Media coverage, Reviews, Story line. Bookmark the permalink.
  • Leon Brozyna

    Indeed, it’s  only a movie.

    It’s entertainment with a message that, hopefully, will inspire viewers to read the book. It won’t change peoples’ minds, but might just pique their interest enough to go out and get the book. And then it’s up to each reader to exercise their minds.

    With appropriate advertising, DVD sales should do even better. Just think of how many people weren’t even aware of the movie even having been made (excluding the Atlanta market, where it was hyped by local talk radio — and just look at how well it did there — it’s still playing in Duluth where it opened April 15!).

    So, let’s see the DVD ads so that sales spur even more interest in the book; book sales shoot up; then, hype the release of Part II in advance of its release. Done properly, Part II should do better in its first weekend than Part I has done to date.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kathleen-Anderberg/100001423184037 Kathleen Anderberg

      Leon, just to be sure, I do not endorse Russ Jackson’s ideas or interpretation of the movie or book. Clearly he’s a mixed-economist liberal type who does not believe in free market principles.  I did find it noteworthy, though, that an Amtrak exec. would plug the movie. Who would guess?!

      • Leon Brozyna

        Indeed, most people that are commenting on the book and movie don’t get it and try to have it both ways. Sort of like Mr. Thompson being a freedom loving man, but not wanting to go to extremes. Probably the ones that have the clearest understanding of what Atlas represents are the most vocal critics — they understand what a threat to the established culture Atlas represents. Despite its shortcomings, it’s still nice to see a piece such as Mr. Jackson penned which isn’t the rantings of someone foaming at the mouth.

        I suspect that the biggest of the movie’s supporters — the Tea Party movement — probably never read (or skipped over) the sixty pages of Galt’s speech (hardcover – a paperback would never last the way I keep rereading it). If they ever truly read it, they would know what an indictment of religion it contains in addition to the one on collectivism.

        These days I wonder why it is that, even as the movie’s fading from view, places such as KOS or HuffPo continue to have pieces attacking Atlas, even if only as a one-line sneer in the middle of an attack piece on yet something else they dislike. And the attacks continue, even in Britain where the movie hasn’t played (yet), where BBC2 ran a piece about the financial disaster of the past few years — placing the blame squarely with Ayn Rand!

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kathleen-Anderberg/100001423184037 Kathleen Anderberg

          Can you get me the link to the BBC2 piece. I’d like to read it and maybe post it on the fb site: Support the “Atlas Shrugged” Movie(s)! You really must get on this site and become a ‘member’ and post stuff. Michael Atlas Shrugged Brown has been recruiting members all over and I am suprised you are not there–or maybe you are. Anyway, become a fb follower on this site and go to the Atlas site I mentioned. You always have something good to contribute. I will ‘friend’ you–ha!

          • Leon Brozyna

            The main story I came across is in the UK publication, The Spectator.

            http://www.spectator.co.uk/coffeehouse/6969378/alan-greenspan-doesnt-exist.thtml

            The actual on-line offering from BBC2 is here:

            http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b011lvb9

            It appears that the program can’t be viewed from the U.S.; at least I couldn’t get it to play.

            There were a couple other articles that I read but can’t locate now; at least Bing isn’t showing them any more. They discussed in greater depth the content of the program, giving the idea that Rand’s philosophy was responsible for the tech boom and financial boom (and subsequent busts). It was all that selfishness and stuff rubbing off on Greenspan and other leading business and tech savvy people.

            I don’t do Facebook — not an antisocial grump, just a personal preference — I prefer my “friends” to be the flesh and blood kind that I can look in the eye. These days my sole consession to “social networking” is my profile on Atlasphere.

          • Leon Brozyna

            Here are some more stories from the U.K. you might find interesting…

            First I’ve heard of this — no plans to distribute Atlas outside the U.S. Is it fact or the writer’s assumption? Only time will tell.

            http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/may/25/ayn-rand-atlas-shrugged

            A rather lengthy profile on Rand from The Telegraph — with a comment from Dr. Binswanger and from some guy named Michael whose name keeps popping up from time to time here on this blog…

            http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/8527015/Ayn-Rand-a-profile.html

            I’m wondering at all this attention in the U.K. press of late. Inspired perhaps by that BBC2 documentary.

  • Leon Brozyna

    Indeed, it’s  only a movie.

    It’s entertainment with a message that, hopefully, will inspire viewers to read the book. It won’t change peoples’ minds, but might just pique their interest enough to go out and get the book. And then it’s up to each reader to exercise their minds.

    With appropriate advertising, DVD sales should do even better. Just think of how many people weren’t even aware of the movie even having been made (excluding the Atlanta market, where it was hyped by local talk radio — and just look at how well it did there — it’s still playing in Duluth where it opened April 15!).

    So, let’s see the DVD ads so that sales spur even more interest in the book; book sales shoot up; then, hype the release of Part II in advance of its release. Done properly, Part II should do better in its first weekend than Part I has done to date.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kathleen-Anderberg/100001423184037 Kathleen Anderberg

      Leon, just to be sure, I do not endorse Russ Jackson’s ideas or interpretation of the movie or book. Clearly he’s a mixed-economist liberal type who does not believe in free market principles.  I did find it noteworthy, though, that an Amtrak exec. would plug the movie. Who would guess?!

      • Leon Brozyna

        Indeed, most people that are commenting on the book and movie don’t get it and try to have it both ways. Sort of like Mr. Thompson being a freedom loving man, but not wanting to go to extremes. Probably the ones that have the clearest understanding of what Atlas represents are the most vocal critics — they understand what a threat to the established culture Atlas represents. Despite its shortcomings, it’s still nice to see a piece such as Mr. Jackson penned which isn’t the rantings of someone foaming at the mouth.

        I suspect that the biggest of the movie’s supporters — the Tea Party movement — probably never read (or skipped over) the sixty pages of Galt’s speech (hardcover – a paperback would never last the way I keep rereading it). If they ever truly read it, they would know what an indictment of religion it contains in addition to the one on collectivism.

        These days I wonder why it is that, even as the movie’s fading from view, places such as KOS or HuffPo continue to have pieces attacking Atlas, even if only as a one-line sneer in the middle of an attack piece on yet something else they dislike. And the attacks continue, even in Britain where the movie hasn’t played (yet), where BBC2 ran a piece about the financial disaster of the past few years — placing the blame squarely with Ayn Rand!

        • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kathleen-Anderberg/100001423184037 Kathleen Anderberg

          Can you get me the link to the BBC2 piece. I’d like to read it and maybe post it on the fb site: Support the “Atlas Shrugged” Movie(s)! You really must get on this site and become a ‘member’ and post stuff. Michael Atlas Shrugged Brown has been recruiting members all over and I am suprised you are not there–or maybe you are. Anyway, become a fb follower on this site and go to the Atlas site I mentioned. You always have something good to contribute. I will ‘friend’ you–ha!

          • Leon Brozyna

            The main story I came across is in the UK publication, The Spectator.

            http://www.spectator.co.uk/coffeehouse/6969378/alan-greenspan-doesnt-exist.thtml

            The actual on-line offering from BBC2 is here:

            http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b011lvb9

            It appears that the program can’t be viewed from the U.S.; at least I couldn’t get it to play.

            There were a couple other articles that I read but can’t locate now; at least Bing isn’t showing them any more. They discussed in greater depth the content of the program, giving the idea that Rand’s philosophy was responsible for the tech boom and financial boom (and subsequent busts). It was all that selfishness and stuff rubbing off on Greenspan and other leading business and tech savvy people.

            I don’t do Facebook — not an antisocial grump, just a personal preference — I prefer my “friends” to be the flesh and blood kind that I can look in the eye. These days my sole consession to “social networking” is my profile on Atlasphere.

          • Leon Brozyna

            Here are some more stories from the U.K. you might find interesting…

            First I’ve heard of this — no plans to distribute Atlas outside the U.S. Is it fact or the writer’s assumption? Only time will tell.

            http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/may/25/ayn-rand-atlas-shrugged

            A rather lengthy profile on Rand from The Telegraph — with a comment from Dr. Binswanger and from some guy named Michael whose name keeps popping up from time to time here on this blog…

            http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/8527015/Ayn-Rand-a-profile.html

            I’m wondering at all this attention in the U.K. press of late. Inspired perhaps by that BBC2 documentary.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Terry-Cantwell/1133977986 Terry Cantwell

    I posted
    this comment on Russ  Jacksons Amtrak
    blog.

     

    Thank you
    for your very objective critique of Atlas Shrugged Part 1.

    The movie
    has its flaws but is very true to the book. I was surprised to see an Amtrak
    fan speak so well of this film.

     

    The irony
    comes in the second section of your blog. On time service of Amtrak appears to
    below 50% much of the time. In related articles “Amtrak Losses to Widen” and
    “All aboard! Amtrak sees surge in ridership”

     

    Personally
    I love rail travel.  I have used Amtrak
    from Albany to Buffalo
    and Seattle to Portland. For two years in Australia Sydney
    City Rail was my main transportation. The Australians have a rail system that
    is very nice. It is funded by a tax on gasoline which makes their gasoline
    twice the price Americans pay.

     

    All we can
    ask is… Who is John Galt?   

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Terry-Cantwell/1133977986 Terry Cantwell

    I posted
    this comment on Russ  Jacksons Amtrak
    blog.

     

    Thank you
    for your very objective critique of Atlas Shrugged Part 1.

    The movie
    has its flaws but is very true to the book. I was surprised to see an Amtrak
    fan speak so well of this film.

     

    The irony
    comes in the second section of your blog. On time service of Amtrak appears to
    below 50% much of the time. In related articles “Amtrak Losses to Widen” and
    “All aboard! Amtrak sees surge in ridership”

     

    Personally
    I love rail travel.  I have used Amtrak
    from Albany to Buffalo
    and Seattle to Portland. For two years in Australia Sydney
    City Rail was my main transportation. The Australians have a rail system that
    is very nice. It is funded by a tax on gasoline which makes their gasoline
    twice the price Americans pay.

     

    All we can
    ask is… Who is John Galt?   

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1483726057 Bradley Hennenfent

    Atlas Shrugged Part I is a Masterpiece!

    Atlas Shrugged is a fantastic movie. I rate it 10 stars plus. It’s actually as good as the book, which is an achievement that rarely happens. There are plenty of negative reviews, from which you can discern the bias of the mainstream media towards socialism and AGAINST freedom and capitalism.

    Atlas Shrugged is an independent film, made for “only” $10 million (according to some sources), and is being self-distributed. Fast Five, the current box office champ, by comparison may have cost $150 million according to Hollywood Reporter. So, for 1/15th the cost, Atlas Shrugged is the clear winner, the underdog story, and the movie that actually means something. Atlas Shrugged could not have been done any better considering the constraints.

    Let me repeat that. Atlas Shrugged is going up against 100 million to 200 million dollar movies. It could not have been done any better at that budget. They did a great job.

    Atlas Shrugged is a huge book. Have you ever seen a movie based on a huge book succeed? Have you seen the Stephen King movie flops: Maximum Overdrive and Pet Cemetery? It’s not easy to turn an opus into a movie. Few are ever successful.

    Kudos to John Aglialoro, a businessman, CEO, Chairman of a Company, and a poker champion for buying the film rights to Atlas Shrugged and making it happen. John Aglialoro is an American Hero for the act of making this movie. (I realized that there are some politics between organizations that I am ignoring.)

    Kudos to the screenwriters: John Aglialoro and Brian O’Toole. When I entered the movie theater all I could think about was: How are they going to handle this or that from the book by Ayn Rand? These two collaborators did a great job. With director Paul Johansson, the trio turned a literary masterpiece into a movie masterpiece, which is almost impossible to do.

    Major Kudos to Graham Beckel, the actor who plays oil tycoon Ellis Wyatt. He’s terrific, as they are all, and he suffers against liberal Hollywood. About Hollywood he says, “Nobody talks to me anymore.” He also said, “…I’ve stopped working since I did Hannity.” One senses that freedom of speech is only okay in Hollywood when it’s not about freedom or liberty. His brother is a prominent democrat, so family events must be very awkward.

    The first time I saw it, I thought the movie was great. It exceeded all expectations. I was stunned by how good it was for a low-budget, independently made, and distributed movie. I sat and watched all the credits. Many of us – strangers – in the theater got up after it was over and talked to each other about how amazing it was.

    I actually went to see Atlas Shrugged Part I a second time, and I never see movies twice. I literally can’t wait for Atlas Shrugged Part II, and Atlas Shrugged Part III. Finally, we have something that might reach the younger generation and wake them up as to how their power is being taken away from them. See it two or three times yourself. Buy some tickets on the way out to support the cause of liberty and give them away. Buy the DVD when the movie theater run is over. Rent it from NetFlicks. This film is destined to be a classic. The following groups should love it: capitalists, freedom lovers, Tea Party members, Republicans, Libertarians, fiscal conservatives, and anyone who likes a fantastic movie that is not just a shoot-em-up car chase extravaganza.

    Atlas Shrugged was so popular in Sebring, Florida that it was held over for second week. You will not hear many good things in the “lamestream media” about Atlas Shrugged, because the movie supports freedom and liberty. So below, I list a few glowing reviews that I have seen.

    It’s telling that as of today 81% of the audience at Rotten Tomatoes liked Atlas Shrugged Part I, while only 13% of the critics liked it.

    I have to leave you with one remaining thought: Who is John Galt?

    Bradley Hennenfent, M.D.
    Physician & Economist (retired)
    Repeal ObamaCare! Stop ObamaNomics!

    The Atlas Shrugged Movie Gallery:
    http://www.atlasshruggedpart1.com/gallery#videos

    I’m So Relieved, The Atlas Shrugged Movie is Fantastic by Judd Weiss:
    http://hustlebear.com/2011/02/28/im-so-relieved-the-atlas-shrugged-movie-was-fantastic/

    Atlas Shrugged Atlas Shrugged Part One: I’ve Seen It. It’s Awesome. by Hans.
    http://www.aetherczar.com/?p=2610

    Atlas Shrugged Brought Tears to His Eyes:
    http://www.atlas-shrugged-movie.com/2011/05/lnc-chairman-would-like-to-see-the-atlas-shrugged-film-presented-at-the-2012-convention/

    John Stossel on Hannity on Why Hollywood Doesn’t Want You to See the Movie Atlas Shrugged:
    http://youtu.be/Pgh96DhU7Yc

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2QJH7OCSK4GUYCYZ3Z3HCQE2SY Michael

    A pleasant surprise of its kind.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2QJH7OCSK4GUYCYZ3Z3HCQE2SY Michael

    A pleasant surprise of its kind.

  • Anonymous

    I’ve noticed that “the numbers” is no longer listing theaters and tickets sales for Atlas. Does anyone why?

  • lostlegends

    I’ve noticed that “the numbers” is no longer listing theaters and tickets sales for Atlas. Does anyone why?

  • Anonymous

    I just checked out Mr. Aglialoro’s Cybex stock price and 5 year history. Cybex has become a penny stock. This being the case I seriously doubt if Mr. Ag will be involved in any more Atlas movies. Cybex may go bust.

  • lostlegends

    I just checked out Mr. Aglialoro’s Cybex stock price and 5 year history. Cybex has become a penny stock. This being the case I seriously doubt if Mr. Ag will be involved in any more Atlas movies. Cybex may go bust.

  • http://www.facebook.com/greg.balaze Greg Balaze

    ” Is the free market the answer to all our problems? Of course not; but
    neither is the free market so infinitely large as to subsidize
    everything else.”

    The free market can do amazing things, if people only let it!

  • http://www.facebook.com/greg.balaze Greg Balaze

    ” Is the free market the answer to all our problems? Of course not; but
    neither is the free market so infinitely large as to subsidize
    everything else.”

    The free market can do amazing things, if people only let it!

  • Anonymous

    Thank you for the added exposure but in the essence of full disclosure This Week at Amtrak is a publication of the United Rail Passenger Alliance and is redistributed by many blogs around the world. For more information into the world of American passenger trains come visit us: http://www.unitedrail.org/

    D.Carleton
    Co-Editor, This Week at Amtrak

  • DCarleton

    Thank you for the added exposure but in the essence of full disclosure This Week at Amtrak is a publication of the United Rail Passenger Alliance and is redistributed by many blogs around the world. Neither myself nor Mr. Jackson (who did not write the movie review) are employees of nor are directly connected with Amtrak. For more information into the world of American passenger trains come visit us: http://www.unitedrail.org/

    D.Carleton
    Co-Editor, This Week at Amtrak