Atlas Shrugged movie an endorsement of government railways? Yeah right!

A new article “Atlas Shrugged pushing high-speed rail?” on CNET begins with the premise that “Contemporary high-speed rail seems to have gotten the nod as a plan worthy of pursuit from the makers of the long-awaited film version of Atlas Shrugged, Ayn Rand’s controversial Objectivist novel in which the railroad industry plays a key role.”

Author Candace Lombardi notes that the trains in the movie (shown below, at left) do, indeed, look much more like today’s high-speed railways (at right, an artist’s rendering of the proposed California high-speed rail line) than like the trains of the 1950s:

Of course, their presence in the movie hardly constitutes and endorsement of the various government-funded high-speed rail projects being advanced around the country and — despite her article’s initial implication that the movie might somehow endorse those projects — Lombardi arrives at the same conclusion herself:

The real-life U.S. high-speed rail project is backed by a combination of federal, state, and private funding. But one could safely assume that the fictional high-speed rail project of “Atlas Shrugged, Part I” is privately funded, in keeping with Rand’s original plot and her personal belief that “the only way a government can be of service to national prosperity is by keeping its hands off.”

Adding a high-speed rail angle to the film might, actually, be the greatest tribute the filmmakers pay to the book’s original intent. Its inclusion could result in a film that’s of interest to all sides of the political spectrum, and, therefore, maximize its profit potential.

This suggests a clever honey-pot: Come to the movie a proponent of high-speed rail; leave the theater a proponent of privatization. I can hear Brian O’Toole’s triumphant muahahaha somewhere in the back of the theater…

About Joshua Zader

Joshua Zader is co-founder of Atlas Web Development and founder of The Atlasphere, a networking directory and dating service for admirers of Ayn Rand's novels with over 20,000 members from around the world.
This entry was posted in Ayn Rand's philosophy, Media coverage. Bookmark the permalink.